.
Feedback

Repairing the World: The Truth About Ending Gun Violence Now

If not now, when.

I’ll spare you.

You don’t need a rabbi to preach to you about how sad the Connecticut massacre was; or about the preciousness of life; or about how we need to appreciate every moment; or about how we should hold our children a little tighter. All of that is true. But we’re all feeling all of those same sad, raw, exposed feelings right now; they have been as fully articulated in recent days as I can imagine; they needn’t be articulated again here.

What I do want to articulate here are some thoughts about what in my Jewish tradition is called “tikkun olam.” It means “repair of the world.” The phrase, in Hebrew, comes from the Jewish mystical tradition and it takes what some would consider to be a radical theological position, while others would see as obvious: that this cannot be what God intended for the world. Not even close. Something is fundamentally broken here; something cries out desperately for repair.

We can do better than this. And we must, and we will. Sometimes, it seems, things have to get so bad that there is a shock to the collective system, a blow to the collective psyche. Such was the news last week regarding the twenty and six – the children and adults mowed down at their school in broad daylight. How is this possible?

It’s possible because our country is awash in guns: handguns, rifles, automatic and semi-automatic weapons with magazine clips capable of holding as many as 100 bullets each (gun purveyors call them "novelty" items). How all of this came to be is of vanishingly little interest to me right now. I’m just a congregational rabbi, and I’m happy to leave the pondering of the underlying societal factors that went into the creation of such a culture of violence here to folks expert in such matters. But however we got to where we are my tradition is very clear about where we must go next: Do not stand idly by the blood of your brother (or sister, or child, or someone else’s child).

The time to act is now. The rabbi’s group to which I belong – the CCAR – has long been on record in favor of saner gun control laws, and was very active in the last fight on this issue, which sadly we lost. Well, the fight is about to resume again even as I hope – and expect - it will be much less of a fight this time; even as I hope – and expect - that many more people this time - folks from both parties, folks from every religious tradition, and folks with no religious affiliation - will be willing to get on board for saner gun control laws.

Petition drives are ongoing, and other actions will I understand be announced soon. Please keep an eye out for these initiatives. In the meantime, please support The Brady Campaign to End Gun Violence. Also look at Demand A Plan and Mayors Against Illegal Guns.

If you’re a member of the Jewish community and would want to sign as such, the Jewish Council for Public Affairs is circulating a petition. A non-denominational petition can be found at We The People.

Finally, please don’t feel dismayed by strong comments you may read on-line which even now, after this unspeakable tragedy, are echoing NRA talking points. The truth will out. And—regardless of what you’ve read or heard—the truth is that the problem is not primarily mental illness, serious as that issue is; only four percent of violence in this country is attributable to mental illness. The truth is that there is no constitutional protection whatsoever for the sort of semiautomatic rifle that killed the kids in Newtown (even Justice Antonin Scalia admits this). The truth is that countries with stricter gun control laws, like Australia and countries in Europe have fewer gun deaths. The truth is that 76% of Americans favor some form of gun control!

The tide has turned; the wind is at our back.  

Rabbi Mark Sameth is the spiritual leader of Joyful Judaism: Pleasantville Community Synagogue an inclusive, progressive synagogue—with members from twenty towns, villages and cities all across Westchester and “A Hebrew School Your Kids Can Love.” Read The New York Times article. Follow Rabbi Mark on Twitter . Weekly meditation at the synagogue every Saturday morning at 9 am is open to the public; everyone—without exception—is welcome and warmly invited. OUR MEMBERSHIP DRIVE IS ON. See “Top Ten Reasons to Join PCS”—as well as service times and events—at www.ShalomPCS.com.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Pleasantville-Briarcliff Manor Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Sonny (Louis) Linder May 18, 2013 at 05:07 pm
CORRECTION TO LAST POST: The last sentence should read: "Let's continue to share, butRead More face-to-face." Thx - Sonny
Sonny (Louis) Linder May 18, 2013 at 06:06 am
Thanks, Jon - you raise important considerations and in a calm, dispassionate way, which IRead More appreciate. As for alternative funding mechanisms, in hindsight I believe they should have been examined and addressed this earlier this year had the decision-making been opened up to the public in a completely bidirectional manner much earlier in this year's budget cycle. A real take-away from this situation, in my opinion, is that we in the community were not given the opportunity to sit down together with sharpened pencils in a public forum and allowed to vet and actually challenge the Administration's assumptions in order to arrive at budget alternatives with the Administration and Board. The comparison you make with Washington is indeed apt in that it reflects the way decisions have slid back to being made in a vacuum and handed down to the voters instead of in a democratic fashion based on budget-to-actuals instead of budget-to-budget figures combined with the practice of over-reserving for expense items while under-estimating revenues. Although the Board did indeed reach out to me and 2 others asking for suggestions, when we re-iterated our request for an open meeting format to include other financially savvy community members, these requests were consistently ignored. Which is why we are in the current position we are in having to decide on Tues on a tax levy cap-busting budget requiring 60% super-majority. Which the public will decide, of course, and we will live with the consequences: either it passes, or the Board and Administration will be forced to rein in the excesses. And much as I love open debate, I restate that online posting leaves does leave a lot to be desired. Let's continue to share, but not face-to-face. Respectfully - Sonny
Jon Satran May 18, 2013 at 12:16 am
Sonny, I like the idea of brainstorming together, thinking outside of the box, but there are someRead More major obstacles that I think you need to consider: 1) A Bond referendum requires a 45 days’ notice period. It cannot be presented for a vote before this year's budget process is concluded. 2) To release reserves based on the hope that a future bond vote would be successful is reckless. What happens if reserves are released and then the bond referendum fails? You would not risk your home finances with this type of risk, would you really risk your school’s financial health? 3) Our tax certiorari reserve was just recently reviewed in consultation with our attorneys and we are appropriately reserved for today’s commercial real estate market. 4) Most importantly, this proposal would create a larger and tougher tax increase next year. In other words, adding $1,000,000 of revenue this year through a loan would require replacing that revenue with an additional $1,000,000 again next year and the year after. Borrow and spend economics does not work as we have seen from the national level. Deficit spending, which has been suggested may or may not work in Washington, but it certainly does not in Briarcliff Manor. When the school’s reserves are exhausted, we will face impactful program cuts or much larger tax levy increases. Respectfully - Jon Satran
JanFisher May 17, 2013 at 10:55 pm
It is so wonderful that, recognizing the importance of STEM and following the recommendation of ourRead More educators, Sal Maglietta and Jon Satran agreed to bring on the district's first director of instructional technology.
McKey Rivers May 10, 2013 at 07:36 pm
Thank you Dr. Sternberg for your thoughtful letter. You hit on an important facet of this electionRead More few if any others have stated: electing Mr. Wasserman and/or Mr. Linder will provide the added benefit of diversity of thought as the Board continues to address difficult, ongoing educational and financial issues. There is a woeful absence of synergy produced by articulation of different views among the current Board members. The absence of a “check and balance” on the current Board is reflected in the inexplicable decision to cancel the May 13 BOE meeting (scheduled since last summer), which is the last meeting prior to the May 21 budget vote and board election. Is there no business for the Board to conduct at this critical juncture or could it be that the Board does not want Briarcliff residents to hear members of the community question the Board about the proposed budget right before the election? Electing either Mr. Linder and/or Mr. Wasserman will immediately benefit the public as the highest vote getter will be seated on May 22 and thus participate in formulating a second budget for public vote that, notwithstanding current BOE scare tactics, can be tax levy compliant and not involve additional program elimination or reduction. There is no doubt that electing Mr. Wasserman and/or Mr. Linder to the Briarcliff School Board will substantially benefit the entire Briarcliff community and provide a much needed check on Board decision making.
Herman Sexton May 10, 2013 at 03:48 pm
Electing Paul Wasserman alone would add a diversity of thought. The guy hears at least a dozenRead More voices in his head. Have you ever spoken to him? Did you pay attention when he was running for Congress for a few weeks? Ugh.